|
Our
last commentary was entitled Millennium
Musings, faintly focussed on the changes that we thought were
inevitable.
Now
the changes are upon us.
At
the time of this commentary an article appears to say that the United
States property and casualty insurance companies have seen their
losses grow by over 40% during the last year, a situation which
most small companies would be very lucky to survive, whether they
be brokers or insurers. Obviously some of the corporate attraction
to Lloyd's also left for greener pastures very quickly.
It's
a funny game if you think of it. There are very few business endeavours
where it is possible to attract so much money with so little guarantee
of an investment reward. The delightful attraction is the relatively
small amount of money that is needed to start, the horror lies in
what is ahead if you don't get it right. Admittedly, the technical
world is far better equipped to assist insurers now than it ever
was but apart from perhaps life insurance it is very, very difficult
for the majority of insurers to derive much benefit from technical
sources. This returns us to our origins where an underwriter, relying
on his knowledge, quotes a price to accept a risk. He was not always
right because insurance is one of the few businesses where you do
not know in advance what your basic cost is. But, if he was wise,
experienced and cautious the chances were that it would be about
right.
Our
problem in recent years has been too much technology and not enough
knowledge. A recent encounter with an underwriter for a small and
growing company led to his assertion that he personally had been
responsible for a doubling of their income in certain classes of
business but when asked whether this was true also of the profit
there were many obscure references to comparative market share etc.,
etc.
After
all there is nothing so satisfying to management as a doubling of
income to go with a doubling of losses!
Well
we know where all that has got us, the question is where do we go
from here. From our position we think it is going to get very difficult.
Obviously the major insurance centres of the world already have
a very tough market, capacity is falling and risks are quoted on
a "take it or leave it" basis. Most of the major domestic
companies are engaged in some form of "navel gazing" where
they will go through endless internal studies, "new teams for
the future" and so on.
So
far, only the high risk classes have been seriously affected but
we are increasingly seeing more and more requests for assistance
on fairly standard lines of business.
Buckle
up - rough road ahead! |